Ice Cream Cottage

About Ice Cream Cottage

Looking for an ice cream shop in Mastic? Ice Cream Cottage is at 1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic, New York. Our Mastic guide covers 2 food and drink spots, and this is one of them.

Ice Cream Cottage is open 7 days a week, usually 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM.

Ice Cream Cottage's menu features 37 dishes and drinks across 5 sections, including Cakes, Other items, Cups, Novelties, and Saucers. Listed prices range from $1.56 to $89.22, with a typical item around $22.31. Dishes worth a look include Large Round (10-12 Servings), Empty Wafer Cone, and Large Cup (4 Scoops).

Available service options are delivery, in-store pickup, onsite services, and takeout. Visitors describe the atmosphere as casual, cozy, and trending. It is especially popular for solo dining. Offerings include coffee.

Accessibility features: wheelchair accessible parking lot. Payment methods accepted: credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments. For questions or orders, call (631) 395-3580.

Quick facts

Category

Ice Cream Shop

Address

1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic, NY 11950

Phone

(631) 395-3580

Hours

Open 7 days a week, usually 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Menu

37 items · $1.56–$89.22

Listing updated

April 2026 · Suggest an edit

How the hours compare

We compared Ice Cream Cottage’s weekday schedule with 223 other ice cream shops in New York. On a typical weekday it opens at 10:00 AM, earlier than 72% of them (the typical opening time is 11:00 AM) and closes at 10:00 PM, in line with the typical 10:00 PM.

In total it is open about 85 hours a week, 10 hours more than the local median of 75. 97% of ice cream shops in New York open on Sundays, and Ice Cream Cottage is one of them.

Compared with 223 other ice cream shops in New York that list their hours in our guide.

• Large Round (10-12 Servings)$68.04

  Vanilla & Chocolate layered with chocolate crunchies in the middle

• Empty Wafer Cone$1.56
• Large Cup (4 Scoops)$9.95
• Spumoni Box Of 4$20.81
• Choc Chip Cookie Deluxe Saucers$24.17

  Pack of 6

• Chocolate Overdose (8-10 Servings)$66.70

  Chocolate Overdose ice cream with Hot Fudge, Chocolate Chip and Brownie Pieces on top

• Take Home Wet Toppings$8.47

  8 oz

• Banana Barge$17.62

  Choice of 3 flavors and 3 toppings.

• Bonnet Cone Box Of 4$20.81

  2 vanilla cone with one with chocolate bonnet and one with cherry bonnet / 2 chocolate cone one chocolate…

• Regular Strawberry Saucers$22.31

  Pack of 6

Typical prices for ice cream shops in New York

Based on 26 menus with 914 priced items from ice cream shops in New York, the median menu item costs $5.00, and half of all items are priced between $3.15 and $9.50.

At Ice Cream Cottage the median listed price is $22.31, higher than the typical $5.00 for ice cream shops in New York.

Calculated from 26 menus in our guide. Prices vary by location and change over time.

Features & amenities

The neighborhood

There are no other places to eat and drink in our guide within half a mile of Ice Cream Cottage, but there is 1 within one mile. By type, the places within a mile include Pizza (1).

Nearest places of other kinds

• PizzaMama Lisa0.7 mi
• Burgers & Fast FoodMcDonald's1.1 mi
• AmericanFriendly's1.2 mi
• Cafes & CoffeeTend Coffee1.2 mi
• Mexican & Tex-MexTaco Bell1.4 mi

No visitor reviews yet. Been to Ice Cream Cottage? Share your experience to help other diners.

More reviews on:Google